ACLU Takes a Strong Stand Against Solitary Confinement
Over the last two weeks, the ACLU has adopted a much more vigorous stance against solitary confinement in U.S. prisons and jails. It has launched a listserv to bring together lawyers, activists, scholars, journalists, and others interested in the subject, and asked the UN Human Rights Council to look into solitary’s torturous effects on prisoners in the United States. On Thursday David Fathi, who heads the organization’s National Prison Project wrote a post on the ACLU’s Blog of Rights, which we reproduce in full below, setting out the group’s broad new approach to this issue.
Fathi,who also is an advisor to Solitary Watch, agreed the ACLU had launched a new policy. “Yes, we have absolutely established fighting solitary confinement as a priority issue,’’ he said in a phone interview on Friday. “We are preparing to fight on all fronts. Historically our work against solitary was primarily litigation. Now we support legislation such as the bill in Colorado,” which would curtail the use of solitary for prisoners with mental illness and developmental disabilities. “We hope for similar bills in other states,” he continued. “In New Mexico, there is legislation that would require a study of solitary.’’ Fathi said the ACLU also looked towards the sort of administrative settlement that took place in Mississippi, where after lengthy litigation, “the state basically closed down its solitary cells” (as we described here last year). He believes the United States has turned a corner on this subject with “a breakthrough in public awareness.’’
Fathi in his blog post puts the number of people in solitary at 20,000, which reflects studies of supermax prisons. However, he said that when you take into account all the different types of segregation, that figure seems conservative and should likely be much higher.
This week, Colorado state Sen. Morgan Carroll and Rep. Claire Levy introduced a bill that would substantially limit the use of solitary confinement in the state’s prisons. S.B. 176 would restrict solitary confinement of prisoners with mental illness or developmental disabilities, who currently make up more than one-third of the state’s solitary confinement population. It would require regular mental health evaluations for prisoners in solitary, and prompt removal of those who develop mental illness. And it would significantly restrict the practice of releasing prisoners directly from solitary confinement into the community, where they are more likely to re-offend than prisoners who transition from solitary to the general prison population before release.
The shattering psychological effects of solitary confinement, even for relatively short periods, are well known. “It’s an awful thing, solitary,” John McCain wrote of his time in isolation as a prisoner of war in Vietnam. “It crushes your spirit and weakens your resistance more effectively than any other form of mistreatment.” The American journalist Roxana Saberi, imprisoned by the Iranian government, said that she was “going crazy” after two weeks in solitary. Imagine, then, that 54 prisoners in Illinois have been in continuous solitary confinement for more than 10 years.
These reforms are long overdue for Colorado and for the nation as a whole. Solitary confinement is an expensive boondoggle – in Colorado, it costs an additional $21,485 per year for each prisoner. And all we get for that investment is an undermining of our public safety. The vast majority of prisoners who are forced to endure long-term isolation are eventually released back into the community, where the devastating impact of solitary confinement leaves them more damaged and less capable of living a law-abiding life.
The United States uses long-term solitary confinement to a degree unparalleled in other democracies, with an estimated 20,000 prisoners in solitary at any one time, and it’s attracting increasing criticism from international human rights bodies. The U.N. Human Rights Committee and Committee Against Torture have both expressed concern about the use of prolonged isolation in U.S. prisons and recommended scrutinizing this practice with a view to bringing prison conditions and treatment of prisoners in line with international human rights norms. And the European Court of Human Rights has temporarily blocked the extradition of four terrorism suspects to the United States on the ground that their possible incarceration in a Supermax prison, where solitary confinement is the norm, could violate the European Convention on Human Rights.
Last week the ACLU urged the U.N. Human Rights Council to address the widespread violations of the human rights of prisoners in the United States associated with solitary confinement. Many of the measures we call for, such as prohibiting solitary confinement of the mentally ill and careful monitoring of prisoners in solitary for mental illness, are also part of Colorado’s S.B. 176. Colorado may be only one state, but the bill’s introduction is a hopeful sign that the United States may, at last, be turning the corner on solitary confinement.
Solitary Watch encourages comments and welcomes a range of ideas, opinions, debates, and respectful disagreement. We do not allow name-calling, bullying, cursing, or personal attacks of any kind. Any embedded links should be to information relevant to the conversation. Comments that violate these guidelines will be removed, and repeat offenders will be blocked. Thank you for your cooperation.
I read the 8th amendment to the constitution states that solitary confinement is banned if deemed to have mental health issues, and this would be cruel and unusual punishment which is against the constitution.
How do I fight to get him out of solitary?
My fiance is in a prison in Wisconsin. He has severe depression which they know and give med’s for, yet they put him in ” THE HOLE” for 120 days and banned my visits for a year.
He seemed ok the first couple weeks, now he is angry, hostile, argumentative, and lately is not calling the two times a week he is allowed.
They put handcuffs on him in the shower, he never gets out of his cell except to shower every four days. Gets no exercise time, never out of his cell during the days he doesn’t get shower and his call to me. How do I help him??
He is in because he was coerced by an inmate to get me to bring in a beading needle to work on jewelry he sell in there. I got banned for it, he got 120 days, which is usually for the most severe cases. Usually they get put in a two man cell after a few days, he will not. Please help me.
These policies are the beginning right? Cause they have policies now about mental health reviews and reviews every 90 days, but the DOC doesn’t follow it and keeps people inside arbitrarily. As long as the DOC is above the law, the legislation can be whatever right? As long as the police are above the law, people can get killed on camera and the police won’t be tried for it. So this legislation is just the beginning right?
I am so happy to see the ACLU fighting to end torture in America’s prisons. The abuse of US prisoners through the use of long term solitary confinement should be outlawed.
I AM REFERRING TO THE ACLU OF NORTHERN CALIFORNIA WHOSE OFFICE IS
IN SAN FRANCISCO.
MY SON NEEDS HELP.
HIS RIGHTS ARE BEING VIOLATED, ALONG WITH THE RIGHTS OF HUNDREDS OF OTHER MENTALLY ILL MEN AND WOMEN BEING HELD IN PRISONS, WHEN THEY SHOULD BE IN HOSPITALS.
If the ACLU is so against ad seg for inmates and for the mentally ill, why have they not agreed to help me get my mentally ill son out of a prison, solitary confinement, when I have sent them letter after letter with proof not only of his being in solitary, but of the staff not taking proper care of his mental health needs and that he has never been convicted of a crime?
ACLU, is it just publicity you want? All you all talk? When I first contacted you, you said you would help. Never got a reply after that first conversation.
JUST SO YOU KNOW, I CONTINUE TO FIGHT FOR HIM AND WILL CONTINUE TO FIGHT FOR ALL THOSE WHO ARE BEING HELD CAPTIVE IN SOLITARY AND WHO ARE MENTALLY ILL. WITH OR WITHOUT YOUR HELP, I WILL GET MY SON OUT OF THERE. THANKS FOR NADA.