One of the first posts we wrote on Solitary Watch, when we started the site back in December, was the story of a teen suffering from depression and PTSD who was living in solitary confinement at Montana State Prison, in conditions that the American Civil Liberties Union did not hesitate to identify as torture. At the time, the teen was 17, and referred to as “Robert Doe.” The ACLU of Montana took up his case after he attempted suicide several times in his cell, and eventually called on the U.N. Special Rapporteur on Torture to intervene on the teen’s behalf.

The case epitomizes the plight of two groups of inmates–juveniles in adult prisons, and prisoners suffering from mental illness. Members of both these groups are disproportionately likely to end up in solitary confinement, even though they are even less equipped than other prisoners to tolerate the effects of long-term isolation.

This week, the ACLU appealed to a federal judge to keep the teen–now 18 and identified as Raistlen Katka–out of solitary confinement. The Billings Gazette reports:

An 18-year-old Montana State Prison inmate who claims he has been treated inhumanely is asking a district court judge to step in to keep him from returning to a solitary cell and other treatment he and his lawyers say is deplorable and scarring.

Raistlen Katka testified Tuesday that he has attempted suicide four times in part due to his treatment at the prison. According to Katka’s attorneys with the American Civil Liberties Union of Montana, an injunction is needed to stop the irreparable harm being done by the prison.

A hearing was held before District Judge Jeffrey Sherlock to give Katka and the prison a chance to argue their cases.

The ACLU filed a lawsuit against the Montana Department of Corrections and the state in December on behalf of Katka, alleging he had been treated illegally and inhumanely. The situation be-came so dire, Katka testified Tuesday, that he twice attempted to kill himself by biting through the skin on his wrist to puncture a vein.

“My thought process was if I don’t die, at least I’ll get out of my cell for 30 seconds,” Katka testified.

Katka is being housed at the Montana State Hospital pending the ruling on the injunction. Testimony will continue today.

Attorneys representing the state said the confinement in the prison’s maximum-security unit helped to protect Katka and other inmates in addition to preserving order at the facility…

Katka and his attorneys say his treatment at the prison has exacerbated his mental illness, which includes depression and post-traumatic stress disorder. They are asking that Katka not be subjected to solitary confinement, not be disciplined with acts such as the removal of personal property from his cell and be transferred to another facility where his needs can be better met.

Maxon Davis, a Great Falls attorney representing the state, argued Katka was a danger to himself and others and that was evident by his criminal history, including violent crimes, dating back to the age of 10.

Katka said he didn’t tell prison officials about his suicidal thoughts for fear of punishment.

At the prison, Katka’s available mental health treatment consists of a staff member knocking on his door once a week and asking if he has any concerns, according to his attorneys, and then he must answer by yelling within earshot of other inmates.

“I think the state has proven in this case that they are not willing or able to provide the mental illness treatment he needs,” said Andree Larose, a Helena attorney representing Katka. “He needs a chance and that chance can’t come from the prison treating him like an animal.”

Katka said much of his time at the prison he was in a solitary cell with only a mattress and blanket and dressed in a smock…


8 thoughts on “Montana Teen Who Faced Torture in Prison Asks Judge to Keep Him Out of Solitary

  1. Barbaric!!
    Help the boy!! one day he will return and he needs to be able to learn how to live…

  2. I hadn’t realized you guys were that new, this particular story was one of the first I blogged about, Well I have had your link up since I started in Jan10 and almost every letter I write to an official in Government I cite this blog

  3. P.S. After I read this story first time I wrote the govenor of Montana relayed this story and told him he/state were an embarrassment to America.

  4. How can we stand behind this kind of punishment? Who are the real insane and violent? The inmates or the the keepers? We need to make the necessary changes in our prisons through new legislation and making the keepers accountable for their treatment and care of the inmates who have mental problems.

  5. poor kid i hope he wins his cse no one should go thow solitary let a lone a kid even and with that disorder it is not going to do any good for him at all may thare be light in the darknes of justice

  6. I hope when this guy gets out he gets a gun and makes himself some justice.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *